How to Negotiate Like a Woman (And Get What You Want)

I love attending good business events and I especially love those that support women in business. It’s great to be with other female business owners and executives, and if I walk away with a nugget or two of new knowledge, it’s icing on the cake.
And that’s exactly what happened last month when I attended a Women’s Leadership Conference in Green Bay, Wis. One of the speakers, Jennifer Pestikas, has 25 years of experience in financial services and she also runs Brave Women at Work, offering individual and group executive and leadership coaching for women.
What she shared about women and negotiations was not only practical; it was also relevant for today’s economic environment and has stuck with me for quite some time.
The gender pay gap is real
On the surface, Jennifer’s topic about tips to win your next negotiation may seem a bit bland. But put in perspective and especially in today’s economy and market, it was spot on.
Consider this: on average, women in the U.S. earn 83 cents for every dollar a man earns in the same job. When you apply some math to that stat you realize a 20-year-old woman who starts a full-time role in 2025 could potentially lose $407,760 compared to a male counterpart over a 40-year career.
That’s a lot of money left on the table–—too much, actually. Jennifer’s mission is to help women learn how to negotiate to get what they deserve and close the pay gap in this country. As she walked us through her 10 tips, I realized many are also relevant for clients who need to negotiate for more dollars to increase headcount or hire contractors. And, they are also equally relevant for independent consultants who may want to negotiate a higher hourly rate.
Negotiate like a woman
Research shows that women often face a double standard when advocating for themselves; for example, women who negotiate are often perceived as demanding or unlikeable for making requests that may be viewed more favorably when made by men.
In a series of experiments published in 2007, researchers found that evaluators were more than twice as reluctant to hire a candidate who negotiated when that candidate was a woman rather than a man. And while these findings are 20 years old, it’s easy to see how backlash like that can linger and make a woman think twice before asking for more.

But that doesn’t mean women don’t negotiate, because they do. A 2024 study published in the Academy of Management Discoveries found that women respondents reported negotiating their salaries more than men. The findings suggest that the problem isn’t necessarily that women aren’t asking for what they want, but rather that the conversation around women and negotiation needs to change. We should consider how their requests are received and whether they are being treated equitably when they do negotiate.
In other words, it’s not enough to tell women to speak up, ask for what they want or negotiate with confidence. We also need to recognize the dynamics that can make negotiating more challenging for women and give them the practical tools to make their case, communicate their value and approach the conversation with intent.
That’s what Jennifer Pestikas provided very concisely.
In fact, her first tip to the audience of women at the conference was to be OK negotiating like a woman. It’s important to recognize the barriers we may face and understand it’s up to us to communicate our value and ask for what we want. No one else will do it for us. Of course, that includes being clear in what we’re asking for, doing our homework, bringing data and writing a script for our request.
There is no shame in practicing how to verbalize what we want. We can do that in front of a mirror or with a trusted adviser who can lend an ear. I fully believe in the value of this and just recently had that experience. I was in the midst of a negotiation and when on a walk with a friend and trusted partner, I talked through some points. After listening to my perspective, they gave me an objective viewpoint that I wasn’t able to see, which brought me new perspective.
I would add that I believe in sleeping on anything you want to send before you actually send it. A fresh mind and a little space do wonders for ensuring clarity.
What this looks like in our world
Jennifer’s tips aren’t just for salary conversations. I see them play out with our consultants all the time. Many of the senior communicators in our network left impressive corporate roles to go independent, and when you’re new to setting your own rates, it’s tempting to underprice. It’s easy to translate a former salary into an hourly number and stop there, or to drop your rate at the first sign of pushback. But the best clients aren’t buying hours. They’re buying judgment built over decades: the crisis you’ve navigated before, the executive you know how to counsel, the plan you can build in a week because you’ve done it a dozen times. The consultants who prepare, who know their value and can say it out loud, consistently land stronger engagements.
Our clients negotiate, too. Communications leaders often have to make the case to a CFO for bringing in fractional or project-based support. Jennifer’s advice applies directly: do your homework, bring data and script the ask. What does it cost the organization to leave the work undone, under hire to stay on budget or hire full-time for a temporary need? Walk in with those numbers and perspectives and it becomes a very different conversation.
Part of what we do at Evo Communications is help both sides land on terms that reflect real value, because the best engagements start with a deal that feels fair to everyone at the table.
It’s about time
The double standard about women in the workplace doesn’t have to exist. We can ask for what we want without the negative stereotypes that come with it. In fact, not only do we deserve it but it’s about time we normalize women negotiators, don’t you think?
I’m curious: what comes to your mind when you think about or encounter a woman in a negotiation?
And you can learn more about Jennifer Pestikas and see all of the 10 negotiation tips here.




Comments